8/16/09 02:14 pm
Thoughts on a Pop Song
Pink – "Please Don’t Leave Me"
“How did I become so obnoxious?”
Interesting that Pink asks that question, as from where I’m standing, it’s her defining trait. She may well ask how she became bipedal; I’ve always thought Pink was obnoxious from the first moment I heard her, back when she was making terrible r&b at the turn of the millennium, rather than the marginally better pop-rock she makes now. And although I do find her obnoxious (in fact, I have difficulty finding other words to describe her), I find her marriage with X-Games athlete Carey Hart kind of perversely fascinating. The first single from her new album, “So What,” was about how glad she was to be rid of him, but they were still on good enough terms that he appeared in the video, and they’re apparently reconciling now. The whole thing gives off the impression of a horrible, “Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf”-esque situation where they’re inextricably attached emotionally but deeply mutually despise each other.
So, after “So What” (maybe the worst song she’s ever recorded), we get the opposite, Pink straightforwardly admitting that she’s a total bitch and abjectly pleading for forgiveness. But it still says a lot that she can’t turn it off entirely; even when she’s begging desperately, she writes lines which sound like passive-aggressive slams (“I am capable of nearly anything/When my heart is/Broken.”) While I have to believe that anyone who would willingly marry Pink could give as good as he got, she undercuts the point of the song a little by spreading the blame around. The video for “Please Don’t Tell Me,” for the record, gutlessly steps around any actual honest feeling by letting Pink depict herself as a Jack Nicholson ax-crazy psycho who ties up her boyfriend and actually fucking winks at the camera, because it’s easier to play a physically abusive lunatic than the emotionally abusive hellbeast that she apparently is.
Part of my response to this song comes from the fact that right before I first heard it, I betrayed my better judgment by watching that video of Chris Brown apologizing for beating the shit out of hiscareer girlfriend. I couldn’t make it through more than a few seconds, but my predominant thought afterward was that apologies aren’t the same as atonement, and that while I’m sure that he is the most regretful person on the planet, that doesn’t mean he won’t do it again. Before Rihanna’s handlers presumably stepped in, Rihanna stayed with Chris Brown for a couple of months after the beating because I’m sure they still felt very passionately about each other; that’s why people stay in abusive relationships. What makes “Please Don’t Leave Me” so frustrating is that (unlike the Chris Brown video, which was clearly a prepared statement written by his PR people) it’s so very convincing and sincere. I feel like I’m the one who’s in an abusive relationship with Pink; I hate her so much but I’m such a sucker for her apologies. (Those delicate la-da-da-das are a nice touch.) The Chris Brown video scares me because he’s so clearly reading from a script and so clearly doesn’t mean it; “Please Don’t Leave Me” is scary because she does mean it. I really do like this song, but its pointed subtext is an endless cycle of misery followed by apologies followed by a short burst of happiness followed by more misery, with no progress being possible. When Pink calls her husband her “perfect little punching bag,” she hits a raw nerve that I’m not sure was intended, but it’s even worse when she sings, “Baby I don’t mean it/I mean it/I promise.” That gives me chills down the spine, and not necessarily in a good way.
Still, I like it when songs have suppressed ugly emotions leak out. Another good example is the Walker Brothers’ “Make It Easy on Yourself,” a breakup song which tries to take the high road but ends up sounding pissy. I don’t like the opposite, when an ugly song projects earnestness, the prime example being “How Do Ya Like Me Now?!” “Please Don’t Leave Me” isn’t the equal of “Who Knew” (which is implicitly also an apology for the kind of person she is), but I’m still surprised at how good it is. Pink’s never been afraid of thrashing herself in song, of course, but I think the reason “Who Knew” and “Please Don’t Leave Me” work is that Pink tempers her angst-laden hatred of herself and others by genuinely expressing affection, whereas “Sober” and “Don’t Let Me Get Me” remind me of Livejournal-y self-obsession only. I predict she’s going to release a few more of those and remind me why I dislike her so much before she sucks me back in with another disarmingly sweet ballad. Fucking bitch.
Pink – "Please Don’t Leave Me"
“How did I become so obnoxious?”
Interesting that Pink asks that question, as from where I’m standing, it’s her defining trait. She may well ask how she became bipedal; I’ve always thought Pink was obnoxious from the first moment I heard her, back when she was making terrible r&b at the turn of the millennium, rather than the marginally better pop-rock she makes now. And although I do find her obnoxious (in fact, I have difficulty finding other words to describe her), I find her marriage with X-Games athlete Carey Hart kind of perversely fascinating. The first single from her new album, “So What,” was about how glad she was to be rid of him, but they were still on good enough terms that he appeared in the video, and they’re apparently reconciling now. The whole thing gives off the impression of a horrible, “Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf”-esque situation where they’re inextricably attached emotionally but deeply mutually despise each other.
So, after “So What” (maybe the worst song she’s ever recorded), we get the opposite, Pink straightforwardly admitting that she’s a total bitch and abjectly pleading for forgiveness. But it still says a lot that she can’t turn it off entirely; even when she’s begging desperately, she writes lines which sound like passive-aggressive slams (“I am capable of nearly anything/When my heart is/Broken.”) While I have to believe that anyone who would willingly marry Pink could give as good as he got, she undercuts the point of the song a little by spreading the blame around. The video for “Please Don’t Tell Me,” for the record, gutlessly steps around any actual honest feeling by letting Pink depict herself as a Jack Nicholson ax-crazy psycho who ties up her boyfriend and actually fucking winks at the camera, because it’s easier to play a physically abusive lunatic than the emotionally abusive hellbeast that she apparently is.
Part of my response to this song comes from the fact that right before I first heard it, I betrayed my better judgment by watching that video of Chris Brown apologizing for beating the shit out of his
Still, I like it when songs have suppressed ugly emotions leak out. Another good example is the Walker Brothers’ “Make It Easy on Yourself,” a breakup song which tries to take the high road but ends up sounding pissy. I don’t like the opposite, when an ugly song projects earnestness, the prime example being “How Do Ya Like Me Now?!” “Please Don’t Leave Me” isn’t the equal of “Who Knew” (which is implicitly also an apology for the kind of person she is), but I’m still surprised at how good it is. Pink’s never been afraid of thrashing herself in song, of course, but I think the reason “Who Knew” and “Please Don’t Leave Me” work is that Pink tempers her angst-laden hatred of herself and others by genuinely expressing affection, whereas “Sober” and “Don’t Let Me Get Me” remind me of Livejournal-y self-obsession only. I predict she’s going to release a few more of those and remind me why I dislike her so much before she sucks me back in with another disarmingly sweet ballad. Fucking bitch.




